Effect of Carpet Effluent and its Dilution on seed
Germination Potential and Seedling Growth of Hordeum vulgare
var. RD 2508
Qurratulane Bari, Nagendra Bhardwaj
Department of Botany, University of Rajasthan, Jaipur, Rajasthan, India- 302004
*Corresponding Author Email:
ABSTRACT:
The study Effect of carpet effluent and its
dilution on seed germination potential
and seedling growth of Hordeum vulgare var.
RD 2508 was conducted at Tonk which is located in north-eastern part of the
Rajasthan state between 75°07' to 76°19' east longitude and 25°41' to 26°34'
north latitude. Aim of the study was to
assess the delirious effects of original carpet effluent (100 %) and its
dilutions viz. 5%,10%,25%, 50% and 75% on the relative germination potential
and seedling growth parameters (7 days)
like root length, shoot length and total dry weight of Hordeum vulgare var.RD 2508 in comparison to the control. It was found that
after 48 hours of sowing, percent germination of seedling showed a decreasing
trend with increasing concentration of the effluent (from 5% - 100%).At 100%
concentration, germination was only 11.66 % while it was 55.0 % and 31.66%
respectively on 50% and 75% concentrations.
Growth parameters for seedling were also
recorded after 7 days. Effect of the effluent content was more on shoot growth
as compared to root, at all the concentrations. Reduction in shoot and root
length were recorded up to 26.66% and 24.59% respectively at 25% effluent
concentration in comparison to control. At higher effluent concentration (75%),
the reduction in shoot length and root length was 63.25% and 54.75%
respectively. At the original concentration of effluent (i.e. 100%) the root
length and shoot length were 2.04 cm. and 1.04 cm. and the reduction percentage
was 83.41% and 82.95% respectively. Plant dry weight also declined along with
the increasing concentration of effluent. It was reduced upto
10.65% at 5% concentration, 17.21% at 10%, 26.22% at 25%, 39.34% at 50%, 58.19%
at 75% and 84.42% at 100% effluent concentrations.
KEY WORDS: Effluent, control, dilutions, percent
germination, growth parameters, shoot length, root length and total dry weight.
INTRODUCTION:
Textiles industry waste water is
characterized primarily by measurements of BOD, COD, colour,
heavy metals; total dissolved and suspended solids (Demmin
1988).Dyeing and printing of textile has been developed with human
civilization. Today, these industries are the backbone of economy in many
developed and developing countries. In India, it contributes to about 25% of
total export earning and provides employment to almost one fourth of the total labour force (Gopal 1994 and Juwarkar et. al 1997).
A considerable amount of waste water
generated by dyeing and printing industries have a strong color, a large amount
of suspended solids, a highly fluctuating pH, salts, heavy metals, sulphides, chlorine, temperature and COD concentration (Gurnham 1965). Due to inefficiency of the dyeing processes,
poor handling of spent effluent and insufficient treatment of wastes of the
dyestuff industries, that lead to dye contamination of various components of environment viz. soil and natural water
bodies (Nigam et al. 1996). Release of colored compounds into water
bodies is undesirable not only because of their impact on photosynthesis of
aquatic plants but also due to the carcinogenic nature of many of these dyes
and their breakdown products (Weisburger 2002), moreover
their presence in an environment like a water body lead to reduced dissolved
oxygen content in water bodies (Gurav et al.
2011).Unfortunately most of these dyes escape conventional waste water
treatment processes and persist in the environment as a result of their high
stability against light, temperature, water, detergents, chemicals and
microbial attack (Couto 2009), so waste water from
such industries pose serious environmental problems because of their color,
high COD and BOD (Kumar et al. 2007). Release of colored compounds into
water bodies is undesirable not only because of their impact on photosynthesis
of aquatic plants but also due to the carcinogenic nature of many of these dyes
and their breakdown products (Weisburger 2002), These
dyes may also be toxic to some of the aquatic organisms, due to their breakdown
products (Hao et al. 2000). Increase in color
fastness, stability and resistance of dyes to degradation have made color
removal from textile waste waters even more difficult (Easton 1995 Waters 1995
and Robinson et al. 2001).
moreover their presence in an environment like a water body lead to
reduced dissolved oxygen content in water bodies (Gurav
et al. 2011), so waste water from such industries pose serious
environmental problems because of their color, high COD and BOD (Kumar et
al. 2007). Nowadays, dyed wastewaters are mainly treated by physical and
chemical procedures which have several shortcomings (Banat et al. 1996).
Biological treatments are more cost-effective, environment friendly and do not
produce large quantities of sludge (Asad et al.
2007 and Kariminiaae-Hamedaani et al.
2007).Improving biological treatment efficiency is the key solution to this
problem due to their possibly complete mineralization of dyes at low cost
(Cetin and Donmez 2006 and Yang et al. 2009).
In recent years, water shortage and
environmental hazards of waste water have promoted the waste water reuse in
irrigation in many arid and semi arid regions.
The effluents
constitute a major part of the total industrial effluents in India. A huge
amount of effluent from textile mills is being discharged on land or into water
courses. This effluent is characterized by its high BOD and COD, dissolved
solids, micro nutrients and heavy metals. The industrial effluents possess
various organic and inorganic chemical compounds. The presence of these
chemicals will show detrimental effects on the development of plant,
germination process and growth of seedling (Kathirvel
2012). Although benefits of wastewater
use in irrigation are numerous but precautions should be taken to avoid short
and long-term environmental risk. Earlier studies have shown that the effect of
an industrial effluent vary from crop to crop (Kaushik
et al. 2005). Hence, it is essential to study the effect of industrial
effluents on the individual crops before their use in agricultural fields (Garg and Kaushik 2008).
The present study
covers the Namda or felted woollen
carpet manufacturing processing in Tonk, during and
after which, the carpet dyeing is applied. A lot of effluent is generated in
the process, which is then allowed to drain towards the sinks of the local
area, and affects the fauna and flora of Tonk.
In the present
study, the delirious effect of various concentrations of carpet effluent were
assessed on the seed germination potential, and overall growth pattern of a
crop Hordeum vulgare
var.RD 2508.
Study area
The Effect of
various concentrations of carpet effluent on relative seed germination and
seedling growth of Hordeum vulgare var. RD 2508 was conducted at Tonk district, which is located in north-eastern part of
the Rajasthan state between 75°07' to 76°19' east longitude and 25°41' to
26°34' north latitude.
MATERIALS AND
METHODS:
The carpet effluent
was brought from Patni namada
manufacturers, RIICO Industrial Area, Tonk (Raj.),
and various concentrations of this carpet effluent were used for irrigating
purpose.
Hordeum vulgare
was
used as a biological test material for seed germination and seedling growth
bioassay. The carpet effluent was diluted in such a way, so that the response
of plant/seedlings towards the effluent dilutions would be observed.
The experiment was
conducted in petri plates. The effluent was diluted
by distilled water to make 5%, 10%, 25%, 50% and 75%, 100% and a control
concentration treatment for proper comparisons on seedling growth and
development. Total 7 concentration variants were prepared in triplicate. Seeds
of Hordeum vulgare were
surface sterilized with 0.1% HgCl2 solution for one minute, washed with double distilled water for 5-7 times, and then dried properly
using blotting paper. Pre-sterilized petri plates
were lined with filter paper over pre-sterilized cotton pads. 20 healthy seeds
were kept equidistantly on top of filter paper. Three replicates were taken for
each respective concentration of effluent. As pretreatment 5 ml of the
respective concentration was added in the related petri
plate on the first day, and 3 ml on 2nd, 4th
and 6th day after sowing, These petri
plates were then kept in BOD incubator at 200C, under proper humid
conditions.
Seedling emergence was
studied after 48 hours and the overall growth was also studied after 7 days.
Root and shoot length of seedlings were then recorded. These seedlings were
then wrapped up in labeled blotting papers and then oven dried at 850C
for 24 hours, and then their dry weights were also recorded.
OBSERVATION AND RESULTS:
After 48 hours of
sowing, percent germination of seedling showed a decreasing trend with
increasing concentration of the effluent (from 5% - 100%).At the 100%
concentration, germination was only 11.66 % while it was 55.0 % and 31.66%
respectively on 50% and 75% concentrations.
Table 1:Effect of various concentrations of carpet effluent on
relative seed germination potential (after 48 h) and seedling growth (after 7 days) of Hordeum
vulgare var.RD 2508
Growth parameter |
Effluent concentrations (%) |
||||||
Control |
5% |
10% |
25% |
50% |
75% |
100% |
|
Germination % (after 48 h) |
95.00 (57/60) |
93.33 (56/60) |
88.33 (53/60) |
76.66 (46/60) |
55 (33/60) |
31.66 (19/60) |
11.66 (7/60) |
%Decrease in seed Germination |
- |
1.75 |
6.67 |
19.3 |
42.1 |
66.67 |
87.72 |
Root length (cm) |
6.1 |
5.8 |
5.5 |
4.6 |
4.02 |
2.76 |
1.04 |
Decrease in Root length (%) |
- |
4.91 |
9.83 |
24.59 |
34.09 |
54.75 |
82.95 |
Shoot length (cm) |
12.3 |
11.6 |
10.9 |
9.02 |
7.54 |
4.06 |
2.04 |
Decrease in shoot length (%) |
- |
5.83 |
11.38 |
26.66 |
38.69 |
63.25 |
83.41 |
Total dry weight (g) |
0.122 |
.109 |
.101 |
.09 |
.074 |
.051 |
.019 |
Decrease in total dry weight (%) |
- |
10.65 |
17.21 |
26.22 |
39.34 |
58.19 |
84.42 |
Growth parameters for
seedling were also recorded after 7 days. Effect of the effluent content was
more on shoot growth as compared to root, at all the concentrations.
Reduction in shoot and
root length were recorded up to 26.66% and 24.59% respectively at 25% effluent
concentration in comparison to control. At higher effluent concentration (75%),
the reduction in shoot length and root length was 63.25% and 54.75%
respectively. At the original concentration of effluent (i.e. 100%) the root
length and shoot length were 2.04 cm. and 1.04 cm. and the reduction percentage
of 83.41% and 82.95% respectively.
Plant dry weight also declined along with the
increasing concentration of effluent. It was reduced to 10.65% at 5% concentration, 17.21% at 10%, 26.22% at
25%, 39.34% at 50%, 58.19% at 75% and 84.42% at 100% effluent concentrations.
DISCUSSION:
In the present study, the delirious effect of various concentrations of
carpet effluent were assessed on the seed germination potential, and overall
growth pattern of a crop Hordeum vulgare var.RD 2508.The
results indicated that after 48 hours of sowing, percent germination of
seedling showed a decreased trend with increased concentration of the effluent
(from 5% - 100%).At the 100% concentration, germination was recorded only 11.66
% while it was 55.0 % and 31.66% respectively on 50% and 75% concentrations.
The inhibition of seed germination occurs at higher levels of total
solids, due to the presence of excess amount of salts and conductivity of the
effluent and it causes depletion of acids from the TCA cycle, which reduces the
respiration rate cumulating in reduction in germination (Kirkby
1968).Rice seeds were treated with different concentrations of spent wash (0%
5%, 10%, 25%, 50%, 75% and 100%), and it was observed that at higher
concentrations (25% and above) speed of germination and seedling growth were
retarded (Sahai et al. 1983).
A trend of inhibition in germination, with increasing the concentrations
of effluent was noted when the rice seeds (Oryza
sativa) were treated in varying concentrations of cardboard factory
effluent, as the maximum of 62% germination was noted down in 25% concentration
and a minimum of 8% germination in pure effluent (100% concentration) (Dixit et
al. 1986). Similar results were
observed in a study in which the effect of textile effluent was studied with respect to
germination and growth of black gram Vigna mungo (L.) Hepper.
At lower concentration the germination ratio and growth were relatively higher
than the control, but gradual decrease in the germination of seeds, seedling
growth with increase in effluent concentration was observed. The best
germination and seedling growth was observed in 25% concentration with growth promoting effect, and
significantly better than control. Beyond 25% effluent, root and shoot length
decreased. Thus the textile mill effluent can be safely used for irrigation
purposes with proper treatment and dilution at 25% (Wins and Murugan 2010).
Impact of different industrial effluents was recorded on germination and
seedling growth of Lens esculentum varieties. Different dilutions (0%, 10%, 20%, 40%, 60%, 80%
and 100%) of textile, refinery and marble factory effluents were used to
irrigate two varieties of lentil (M-93 and NARC-02-4) and it was found that the textile effluent was most
injurious as it’s all concentrations caused a reduction in the length parameters
of the two varieties. Roots were more affected than shoots. Whereas various
concentrations of effluents from marble industry and refinery were stimulatory for the
growth of both the varieties (Yasmin et al. 2011).
In the present study also, a sharp decrease in germination potential of
seeds of Hordeum vulgare
at 75% and 100% carpet effluent concentrations i.e. 31.66% and 11.66%, along
with a decrease of 58.19% and 84.42% in the total dry weight content of the
seeds of Hordeum vulgare
on 75% and 100% effluent concentrations respectively.
Kaushik et al.
(2005) conducted experiments to study the effect of textile effluents in
varying concentrations, (0-100%) (untreated and treated) on seed germination
percentage, delay Index (DI), plant shoot and root length, plant biomass,
chlorophyll content and carotenoid content on three
different cultivars of wheat (Triticum aestivum).As the textile effluent does not show any
inhibitory effect on seed germination and other plant characters at low
concentration, (6-25%) but seed germinated in undiluted effluents did not
survive for a longer period.
Rehman et al. (2009)
used varying levels of treated and untreated textile effluents and were applied
to germinating seeds of some winter vegetables and their effect was evaluated
on germination and early growth stage using seed germination, growth, and
biochemical attributes. From the results, it was found that textile effluent
reduced seed germination and early growth of all vegetables. However, this
effect was more pronounced at the highest concentration of textile effluent.
Singh and Yadav (2012)
conducted few laboratory experiments to study the effect of different
concentrations of distillery effluent (0%, 6.25%, 12.5%, 25%, 50%, 75% and
100%) on seed germination (%), vigor index (VI), plant shoot length and root
length of three different cultivars of wheat. The distillery effluent has less
inhibitory effect on seed germination at low concentration (25%). The other
reported plant parameters also followed the similar trend. At higher
concentration effluent has a detrimental effect on all the studied cultivars of
wheat WH-147, PBW-343 and PBW-373.
Khan et al. (2011) carried out experiments to
evaluate the effect of textile factory effluents (0%, 10%, 25%, 50%, 75% and 100%)
on germination and physiological parameters like, biomass production,
chlorophyll content in leaves, root development in three leguminous crops viz.
pea (Pisum sativum
L.), lentil (Lens esculentum L.) and Gram (Cicer arietinum L.). Plants
exhibited a substantial reduction in total germination %, root and shoot dry
weight, number of root branches per plant, mean extension rate (MER),relative
multiplication rate (RMR),relative growth rate (RGR) and chlorophyll contents
when grown with higher concentrations (50% and 100% ) of textile effluents.
In the present study also, at low concentrations of carpet effluent (up
to 5%), there was very less or negligible effect on the root length, shoot
length, number of tillers, number of leaves, root weight, shoot weight and leaf
weight, leaf area (cm2), but at higher concentrations of carpet
effluents, a significant reduction in the above mentioned vegetative parameters
was observed.
Seed quality characters of Neem (Azadirachta indica)
were evaluated with industrial effluents of various industries along with
textile dyeing industry both as raw and in different dilutions (10-50%) and
revealed that with raw material irrigation, the germination was inhibited
completely in the case of dyeing and automobile effluents, and continuous
irrigation with the raw elements was found to cause seedling damages as well,
however with diluted effluent, the germination percentage increased along with
the seedling vigor as compared to the raw effluent (Thiruvaruldevi
et al. 2006).
The findings are similar to the present study, where the dyeing effluent
has exhibited a trend of lowering the germination potential of seeds of Hordeum vulgare along
with an increase in the dyeing effluent concentrations. The trend continues in
the pot experiments, where the effects were getting more and more significant
during the Ist, IInd and III harvesting respectively, according to the
various vegetative parameters observed during the study, and the effect was
more delirious at 75% and 100% effluent. The results correlates with the
findings of Karunyal et al. (1994), where the
chlorophyll and protein contents were decreased with 75% and 100% tannery
effluent on the seed germination of Acacia holosericea
and Leucaena leucocephala.
Similiar results were observed on the seedling
growth, seedling germination, biomass and crop yield of Raphanus
sativus var. Pusa Chetki (Raddish) and
Hibiscus esculentus versha uphar (Bhindi) as the trend
of the decrease in germination percentage with increasing of the effluent
concentration continued, as the study revealed the assessment of the toxicity
of the surgical effluent (Yadav and Meenakshi 2007).
It is concluded that at higher concentrations of the discharged effluent,
the plants did not tolerate the toxic effect and manifested in decline of the
general health of plant and affected the yield of the crop, due to various
harmful chemicals present in the effluent. It is therefore recommended strongly
that for the conservation of biodiversity and ecosystem, Namda
effluent should be treated properly or it should be diluted to the permissible
limit, so that it may not affect the local fauna and flora along with the human
population of the area.
REFERENCES:
1.
Asad,
S. Amoozegar, M.A. and Pourbabaee,
A. Sarbolouki, M.N. and Dastgheib,
S.M.M. 2007. Decolorization of textile azo dyes by newly isolated halophilic
and halotolerant bacteria, Bioresource
Technology. 98:2082–2088.
2.
Cetin, D., and Donmez,
G.2006. Decolorization of reactive dyes by mixed
cultures isolated from textile effluent under anaerobic conditions. Enz Microbiol and Technol. 38:
926–930.
3.
Couto,
S. R. 2009. Dye removal by immobilized fungi. Biotechnology Advances.
27:227–235.
4.
Demmin,T.R.
and Uhrich,K.D.1988. Improving carpet wastewater treatment. American dyestuff
Reporter. June: 13.
5.
Dixit,A.Laxman,M.
and Srivastava,S.K.1986. Effect of cardboard factory effluent of seed
germination and early seedlings growth of rice seeds. Seed Res. 14:66-71.
6.
Easton, J.R.1995. The dye makers view in color in dye
house effluent. Society of dyers and colorists. Pages: 9-21.In Cooper, P.
(ed.).The Alden press, Oxford (UK).
7.
Garg, V.K. and Kaushik, P. 2008. Influence of textile
mill wastewater irrigation on the growth of sorghum cultivars. Applied Ecology and Environmental Research.
6: 1-12.
8.
Gopal, B.1994. Conservation of inland waters
in India, An overview, Verh. Internat.Verein Limnol.
25: 24-94.
9.
Gurav,
A. A. Ghosh, J. S. and Kulkarni,
G. S. 2011. Decolorization of Textile Dye Vat Blue 66
by Pseudomonas desmolyticum
NCIM 2112 and Bacillus megaterium NCIM 2087. Research Journal of Applied
Sciences, Engineering and Technology. 3: 689-692.
10.
Gurnham, C.F.1965.Industrial waste control.Academic press, New York.
11.
Juwarkar,A.Padole,L.M.and Oke,B.H.1997. HRTS
effluent treatment. The Indian Textile
Journal.14.
12.
Kariminiaae-Hamedaani,
H.R. Sakurai, A. and Sakakibara, M. 2007. Decolorization of synthetic dyes by a new manganese peroxidase producing white rot fungus, Dyes Pigments. 72: 157–162.
13.
Karunyal,S.Renuga,G. and
Paliwal,K.1994.Effects of tannery effluent on seed germination,leaf
area, biomass and mineral content of some plants.Bioresour.Technol.47:215-218.
14.
Kathirvel,
P.2012. The effect of dye factory effluent on growth, yield and biochemical
attributes of Bengal Gram (Cicer arietinum L.).International Journal of Applied
Biology and Pharmaceutical Technology.3:146-150.
15.
Kaushik,
P. Garg, V.K. and Singh, B. 2005. Effect of textile
effluent on different cultivar of wheat.
Biores. Technol. 96: 1189-1193
16.
Khan,M.G.Daniel,G.Konjit,M.Thomas,A.Eyasu,S.S.andAwoke,G.2011.Impact
of textile waste water on seed germination and some physiological parameters in
Pea (Pisum sativum), Lentil
(Lens esculentum
L.) and Gram(Cicer arietinum L.).Asian
journal of plant sciences. 10:269-273.
17.
Kirkby,
E.A.1968. Influence of ammonium and nitrate nutrition on the anion balance and
nitrogen and carbohydrate metabolism of white mustard plants grown in dilute
nutrient solutions. Soil Sci : 105-141.
18.
Kumar, K. Devi, S.S. and Krishnamurthi,
K. 2007. Decolorisation and detoxification of Direct
Blue-15 by a bacterial consortium, Bioresource
Technology. 98: 3168–3171.
19.
Nigam,P.
Banat, I.M. Singh, D. and Marchant, R. 1996. Decolorization of effluent from a textile industry by a microbial
consortium. Biotechnol. Lett.
18:117.
20. Rehman, A. Bhatti,
H. N.and Athar, H.R. 2009.
Textile Effluents Affected Seed Germination and Early Growth of Some Winter
Vegetable Crops: A Case Study. Water
Air Soil Pollut.
198:155–163.
21.
Robinson, T. McMullan,G. Marchant,R. Nigam,P.2001. Remediation of dyes in textile effluent: A
critical review on current treatment technologies with proposed
alternative.Biores.Technol.77:247-255.
22.
Sahai et al. 1983 Sahai, R. Shukla, N. Jabeen, S.
and Saxena, P.K. 1983. Pollution effect of distillery waste
on the growth behaviour of Phaseolus radiatus L. –Environ. Pollun
(Series A). 37:245-253.
23.
Singh, B. and Yadav,
A.2012. Effect of Distillery Effluent on Different Wheat Cultivars. World
Journal of Environmental Biosciences. 1: 38-41.
24.
Thiruvaruldevi,
A. Raja, K. Vanangamudi, K. and Vanangamudi,
M. 2006. Revitalization of industrial effluents for enhancing seed germination
and seedling survival. Advances in Seed science and technology. Vanangamudi, K. Natarajan, K. Unmarani, R. Bharathi, A. Natesan, P. and Natarajan,
N.(eds.) Agrobios publisher Jodhpur, India.
25.
Waters, B.D.1995.The regulators view in color in dye
house effluent. Pages: 22-30.In Cooper, P. (ed.) Society of dyers and
colorists. The Alden press, Oxford (UK).
26.
Weisburger, J.H. 2002. Comments
on the history and importance of aromatic and heterocyclic amines in public
health. Mutat. Res. 506/507:9-20.
27.
Wins, J. A. and Murugan,
M. 2010. Effect of textile mill effluent
on growth and germination of black gram-
Vigna mungo (L.) He:er. International Journal of Pharma and Bio Sciences. 6:1-7.
28.
Yadav,J.
and Meenakshi,P.2007. Impact of surgical effluent on germination,seedling growth and yield of selected
crops.J.Ecotoxicol.Environ.Monit.17:151-158.
29. Yang, Q., Li, C., Li, H., Li, Y. and Yu,
N.2009. Degradation of synthetic reactive azo dyes
and treatment of textile wastewater by a fungi consortium reactor. Biochem. Eng. J. 43: 225-230.
30.
Yasmin,
A. Nawaz, S. and Ali, S. M. 2011.Impact of industrial
effluents on germination and seedling growth of Lens esculentum varieties. Pak. J.
Bot. 43: 2759-2763
Received on 22.01.2013 Accepted
on 25.07.2013
Modified on 28.08.2013 ©A&V
Publications all right reserved
Research J. Science and Tech 5(4): Oct.- Dec.., 2013 page 449-453