Cardioprotective Activity of Draksharishta
on Isoproterenol Induced Myocardial Infarction
Preeti Tiwari*
Head of
Department of Pharmacognosy, Dr. K. N. Modi Institute
of Pharmaceutical Education and Research, Modinagar,
Uttar Pradesh, India.
*Corresponding Author E-mail: preetitiwari198311@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT:
The present study was designed to evaluate
the cardio protective activity of Draksharishta-T, Draksharishta-M prepared by traditional and modern methods
respectively and its marketed preparation on isoproterenol
(ISO) induced myocardial infarction (MI) in albino rats. Wistar albino rats of
either sex were randomly divided into 06 groups comprising 06 animals in each
group as normal control, ISO control, pretreatment with Inderal*10
(10 mg/kg) per os, pretreatment with Draksharishta-T, M and its marketed preparation at the dose
of 2 ml/kg per os per day for 30 days. MI was induced
in all the groups except normal control, by administering ISO (85 mg/kg) intraperitoneally, on 29th and 30th
day. On 31st day, level of serum marker enzymes was determined and
serum lipid profile was also measured. Then, animals were subsequently sacrificed;
hearts were removed, weighed and immediately processed for biochemical studies.
Pretreatment with Inderal*10 and all the test
preparations of Draksharishta significantly prevented
the ISO-induced adverse changes in the level of serum marker enzymes as creatine kinase (CK-MB), lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), aspartate aminotransferase (AST) and alanine
aminotransferase (ALT) and also improved serum lipid
profile. All the test formulations pretreated groups showed significant
increase in glutathione (GSH) content and significantly reduced malonyldialdehyde (MDA). Thus, experimental finding suggests that the cardio protective activity
of Draksharishta-T, M and its marketed preparation
may be due to an augmentation of endogenous antioxidants as GSH and inhibition
of lipid peroxidation of cardiac membrane.
KEYWORDS: Myocardial infarction, Isoproterenol, Draksharishta.
INTRODUCTION:
Myocardial infarction (MI) is
the most lethal manifestation of cardiovascular diseases and has been the
object of intense investigation by clinicians and basic medical Scientists. It
is the necrotic condition that occurs due to imbalance between coronary blood
supply and demand1. Currently, there is increasing realization that
herbs can influence the course of heart diseases and its treatment by providing
an integrated structure of nutritional substances which aid in restoring and
maintaining balanced body systems2-3.
Use of herbs for the treatment
of cardiovascular diseases in Ayurveda, Chinese and Unani systems of medicine has given a new lead to
understand the pathophysiology of these diseases.
Therefore, it is rational to use the formulations which have been prepared by
using natural resources for identifying and selecting inexpensive and safer
approaches for the management of cardiovascular diseases along with the current
therapy.
Draksharishta is a polyherbal
hydroalcoholic ayurvedic
preparation and is used as blood purifier, in the treatment of anaemia and advised as a choice of remedy in respiratory
problems. The chief ingredient of Draksharishta is draksha, fruits of Vitis vinifera4.
The composition and properties of fruits of Vitis vinifera, have been extensively
investigated and it was reported that they contain large amount of phenolic compounds as catechins, epicatechin, quercetin, gallic acid, dimeric, trimeric and tetrameric procyanidins5.
These compounds have many favourable effects on human
health such as lowering of human low density lipoproteins, reduction of heart
disease and cancer etc6-9.
Therefore, we undertook the
present investigation to evaluate the cardio protective effect of Draksharishta-T and Draksharishta-M
prepared by traditional and modern methods respectively on isoproterenol
(ISO) induced myocardial infarction (MI) in albino rats.
MATERIALS AND METHODS:
Preparation of Draksharishta-T
This was prepared by the method as given in
The Ayurvedic Formulary of India, Part-I4.
All the ingredients of Draksharishta were procured
from local market, Jamnagar while jaggery was
procured from local market, Mehsana. Authentication
of all the ingredients of Draksharishta was done by
Dr. G. D. Bagchi, Scientist, Department of Taxonomy
and Pharmacognosy, Central Institute of Medicinal and Aromatic Plants, Lucknow.
Prepared herbarium has been deposited in the Central Institute of Medicinal and
Aromatic Plants, Lucknow for future reference. Identification of all the
individual plant material was done as per The Ayurvedic
Pharmacopoeia of India. Quantity of ingredients taken for the preparation of
batch size 3.25 l of Draksharishta has been
calculated according to the formula as given in The Ayurvedic
Formulary of India, Part-I, 2000.
According to this method, dried fruits of Vitis vinifera
after proper crushing were placed in polished vessel of brass along with
prescribed quantity of water (13 l), and allowed to steep overnight. After overnight
steeping, this material was warmed at medium flame until the water for
decoction reduced to one fourth of the prescribed quantity (3.25 l), then the
heating was stopped and it was filtered through unstarched
muslin cloth in cleaned and fumigated vessel and after that jaggery
was added and mixed properly. Then the prescribed quantity of coarsely powdered
prakshepa dravyas as Cinnamomum zeylanicum (stem
bark), Eletteria cardamomum (seeds),
Cinnamomum tamala
(leaves), Mesua ferrea
(stamens), Callicarpa macrophylla
(flowers), Piper nigrum
(fruits), Piper longum
(fruits), Embelia ribes (fruits)
were added and then dhataki flowers (Woodfordia floribunda) were added for inducing
fermentation and after that this sweet filtered fluid was placed for
fermentation in incubator for fifteen days at 33şC±1 şC. After fifteen days
completion of fermentation was confirmed by standard tests10. The
fermented preparation was filtered with unstarched
muslin cloth and kept in cleaned covered vessel for further next seven days.
Then, it was poured in clean amber coloured glass
bottles previously rinsed with ethyl alcohol, packed and labelled
properly.
Preparation of Draksharishta-M
Method of preparation of Draksharishta-M was same as followed for Draksharishta-T only dhataki flowers
were replaced by yeast for inducing fermentation11.
Animals
Adult wistar albino rats, weighing between 200-220g of either sex
were acclimatized to normal environmental conditions in the animal house for
one week. The animals were housed in standard polypropylene cages and
maintained under controlled room temperature (22oC±2oC)
and humidity (55±5%) with 12:12 hour light and dark cycle. All the animals were
given a standard chow diet (Hindustan Lever Limited), and water ad libitum.
The guidelines of the Committee for the Purpose of Control and Supervision of
Experiments on Animals (CPCSEA) of the Government of India were followed and
prior permission was granted from the Institutional Animal Ethics Committee
(CPCSEA No. 07/09).
Experimental Procedure
The cardio
protective effect of Draksharishta-T, Draksharishta-M and marketed Draksharishta
was determined on ISO-induced MI in albino rats12. All the animals
were randomly divided into six groups comprising six animals in each group.
Animals of normal control and positive control group received normal saline as
vehicle and positive control animals received ISO (85 mg/kg) intraperitoneally (i.p.).
Remaining groups were pretreated with Inderal*10 (Piramal Healthcare Limited, Baddi,
India) which contains propranolol hydrochloride 10 mg
at the dose of 10 mg/kg per os per day13
and with Draksharishta-T, Draksharishta-M
and marketed Draksharishta at the dose of 2 ml/kg per
os per day for thirty days to all the ISO treated
animals. MI was induced in all the groups except normal control by
administering ISO (85 mg/kg) intraperitoneally on 29th
and 30th day, at an interval of 24 h. At the end of the experimental
period, i.e. 24 h after the last injection of ISO, on 31st day, the
blood samples were withdrawn by retro orbital bleeding under mild ether anaesthesia and were centrifuged at 2000 rpm for 10 minutes
for the separation of serum. The animals were subsequently sacrificed with an
over dose of ether anaesthesia, hearts were removed,
weighed and immediately processed for biochemical studies. The ratio of heart
weight to body weight (mg/g) was also measured.
Biochemical analysis of serum
The separated
serum was analysed for various serum marker enzymes
as lactate dehydrogenase14, creatine
kinase15, alanine aminotransferase
and aspartate aminotransferase16. Serum
was also assessed for lipid profile as serum cholesterol17, serum
HDL and LDL18 and triglycerides19. Span and Erba diagnostic kits were used for the measurement of all
these serum marker enzymes.
Biochemical analysis of myocardial tissue
A 10% homogenate
of myocardial tissue was prepared in 50 mM phosphate
buffer of pH 7.4. This homogenate was
centrifuged at 2000 rpm for 10 min and an aliquot of the supernatant was used
for the estimation of malonyldialdehyde20 and glutathione21.
Statistical analysis
The results are
expressed as mean ± SEM. Statistical analysis of data among the various groups
was performed by using one way analysis of variance (ANOVA) followed by Tukey’s test using Graph Pad Prism software of statistics.
RESULTS:
The effects of
pretreatment of Draksharishta-T, Draksharishta-M
and its marketed preparation on serum lactate dehydrogenase
(LDH), creatine kinase
(CK-MB), aspartate aminotransferase
(AST) and alanine aminotransferase
(ALT) in ISO-induced MI in albino rats have been shown in Table 1. Results showed that in ISO-control group significant (P<0.001) increase was observed in the
level of serum marker enzymes as serum LDH, CK-MB, AST and ALT as compared to
normal control group. Pretreatment with Draksharishta-T,
M at the dose of 2 ml/kg orally for thirty days significantly (P<0.001) reduced serum LDH, CK-MB,
AST and ALT in ISO-induced MI in albino rats as compared to ISO- control group.
Pre-treatment with marketed Draksharishta also showed
similar effects on serum LDH, CK-MB, AST and ALT nearby same as produced by Draksharishta-T and M in ISO- induced MI in albino rats.
Pretreatment with
all the test preparations of Draksharishta
significantly improved serum lipid profile in ISO- induced MI in albino rats as
compared to ISO-control group as shown in Table
2. Pretreatment with Draksharishta-T, M and its
marketed preparation significantly (P<0.001)
reduced serum cholesterol, triglycerides (TG), serum low density lipoproteins
(LDL) while showed significant (P<0.001)
increase in serum HDL as compared to ISO- control group.
Draksharishta-T, M and its marketed
preparation pretreated groups significantly (P<0.001) reduced the increased heart weight and heart to body
weight ratio as compared to ISO-control group as shown in Table 3.
It was observed
that ISO-control group showed significant (P<0.001)
rise in the basal level of myocardial lipid per-oxidation marker malonyldialdehyde (MDA) in myocardial tissue and caused
significant (P<0.001) decrease in
glutathione (GSH) content in cardiac tissue. Pretreatment with Draksharishta-T, M and its marketed preparation
significantly (P<0.001) reduced
MDA content and showed significant (P<0.001)
rise in GSH content in cardiac tissue as compared to ISO – control group as
shown in Table 4.
Table 1. Effect of
Draksharishta-T, M and marketed Draksharishta
on serum LDH, CK-MB, ALT and AST in ISO-induced MI in albino rats
Group |
Dose( ml/kg/day p.o.) |
LDH( U/L) |
CK-MB( U/L) |
ALT(IU/L) |
AST(IU/L) |
Normal
control |
2ml
normal saline |
192.51±
2.48 |
107.35±1.96 |
64.21±4.72 |
118.54±4.61 |
ISO
control |
2 ml
normal saline |
506.12±6.25a |
278.50±3.24a |
176.15±6.48a |
304.48±3.82a |
Inderal*10+ISO |
10 mg |
212.42±2.92b |
123.56±4.28b |
85.42±3.17b |
167.24±4.26b |
Drst-T+ISO |
2ml |
270.52±3.71b |
161.56±1.82b |
102.54±4.18b |
190.21±3.79b |
Drst-M+ISO |
2ml |
273.16±2.94b |
163.14±4.17b |
104.26±3.62b |
192.58±2.78b |
Marketed
Drst+ISO |
2ml |
272.41±
2.43b |
164.28±1.46b |
103.81±2.97b |
192.96±4.12b |
All values are expressed as mean ± standard
error mean (n = 6).
a P<0.001
significant as compared to normal control
b P<0.001
significant as compared to ISO control
ISO, isoproterenol;
MI, myocardial infarction; Drst, Draksharishta
Table 2. Effect of
Draksharishta-T, M and marketed Draksharishta
on serum lipid profile in ISO-induced MI in albino rats
Group |
Dose ( ml/kg p.o./day) |
Serum cholesterol ( mg/dl) |
Serum HDL ( mg/dl) |
Serum LDL ( mg/dl) |
Serum triglycerides ( mg/dl) |
Normal
control |
2 ml
normal saline |
148.52±5.81 |
53.24±3.72 |
76.92±6.46 |
89.74±4.67 |
ISO
control |
2 ml
normal saline |
320.29±6.24a |
29.30±1.72a |
252.41±9.26a |
206.15±5.92a |
Inderal*10 +ISO |
10 mg |
161.48±12.21b |
50.12±4.26b |
90.25±1.48b |
102.41±2.73b |
Drst-T+ISO |
2 ml |
178.53±1.87b |
47.79±2.81b |
105.43±2.36b |
126.55±1.93b |
Drst-M+ISO |
2 ml |
180.84±2.98b |
47.21±3.18b |
107.14±4.92b |
132.45±2.49b |
marketed
Drst+ISO |
2 ml |
180.16±4.16b |
47.32±1.68b |
106.84±3.58b |
130.0±3.71b |
All values are expressed as mean ± standard
error mean (n = 6).
a P<0.001
significant as compared to normal control
b P<0.001
significant as compared to ISO control
ISO, isoproterenol;
MI, myocardial infarction; Drst, Draksharishta
Table 3. Effect of
Draksharishta-T, M and marketed Draksharishta
on heart weight and heart to body weight ratio in ISO-induced MI in albino rats
Group |
Dose ( ml/kg p.o./day) |
Heart weight (mg) |
Body Weight ( g) |
Heart to body weight ratio ( mg/g) |
|
On 1st Day |
After 14 days |
||||
Normal
control |
2 ml
normal saline |
972±46 |
208.6±3.8 |
209.2±2.7 |
4.646±0.42 |
ISO
control |
2 ml
normal saline |
1215±37a |
208.2±4.6 |
208.4±2.2 |
5.830±0.38a |
ISO +
Inderal*10 |
10 mg |
994±42b |
208.1±2.4 |
207.9±4.1 |
4.781±0.51b |
ISO+Drst-T |
2 ml |
1029±51b |
210.8±5.4 |
210.6±2.9 |
4.886±0.24b* |
ISO+Drst-M |
2 ml |
1033±34b |
211.2±4.9 |
211.0±3.6 |
4.895±0.47b* |
ISO +
marketed Drst |
2 ml |
1031±41b |
211.0±3.8 |
210.8±5.6 |
4.890±0.37b* |
All values are expressed as mean ± standard
error mean (n = 6).
a P<0.001
significant as compared to normal control
b P<0.001;
b*P<0.01 significant as compared
to ISO control
ISO, isoproterenol;
MI, myocardial infarction; Drst, Draksharishta
Table 4. Effect of
Draksharishta-T, M and marketed Draksharishta
on heart MDA and GSH concentration in ISO-induced MI in albino rats
Group |
Dose ( ml/kg p.o.
/Day) |
MDA( nmol/g
tissue) |
GSH ( µmol/g tissue) |
Normal
control |
2 ml
normal saline |
110.12±4.28 |
1.48±0.081 |
ISO
control |
2 ml
normal saline |
246.23±7.43a |
0.89±0.043a |
Inderal*10+ISO |
10 mg |
125.27±3.72b |
1.21±0.036b |
Drst-T+ISO |
2 ml |
147.28±2.89b |
1.12±0.048b |
Drst-M+ISO |
2 ml |
149.57±3.54b |
1.10±0.037b |
marketed
Drst+ISO |
2 ml |
149.13±4.27b |
1.11±0.059b |
All values are expressed as mean ± standard
error mean (n = 6).
a P<0.001
significant as compared to normal control
b P<0.001
significant as compared to ISO control
ISO, isoproterenol;
MI, myocardial infarction; Drst, Draksharishta
DISCUSSION:
Isoproterenol (ISO), a synthetic
catecholamine in higher dose produces cardiotoxic
effects on the myocardium. Amongst the various mechanisms proposed to explain
ISO-induced cardiac damage, generation of highly cytotoxic
free radicals through the auto-oxidation of catecholamines has been implicated
as one of the important causative factor22. This free radical
mediated lipid per-oxidation of membrane phospholipids and consequent changes
in membrane permeability is the primary target responsible for cardio toxicity
induced by ISO.
Studies have shown that oxidative stress
results in the reduction of the efficacy of the β-adrenoceptor
agonists probably due to reduction in c AMP formation. The reduction in of
maximal β-adrenoceptor mediated response might
be the result of cytotoxic aldehydes
that are produced during the oxidative stress. This β-adrenoceptor
hyper stimulation leads to cardio toxicity23. Oxidative stress may
also depress the sarcolemmal Ca2+
transport and result in the development of intracellular Ca2+ overload
and ventricular dysfunction24. Hence, therapeutic intervention with
therapeutic activity may be useful in preventing these deleterious changes.
Changes in serum LDH and CK-MB
activities have been considered some of the important biomarkers of MI. A
significant increase in serum LDH, CK-MB, AST and ALT was observed in ISO
control group. Pre-treatment with Draksharishta-T, Draksharishta-M and marketed Draksharishta
in ISO-induced MI in albino rats significantly restored serum LDH, CK-MB, AST
and ALT activity as compared to the ISO control group was suggestive of their
cardio-protective effect.
In ISO control group significant
rise in serum lipid profile was also observed. Pre-treatment with Draksharishta-T, Draksharishta-M
and marketed Draksharishta for thirty days significantly reduced serum cholesterol, LDL
and TG level while showed significant rise in serum HDL level in ISO-induced MI
in albino rats. A rise in LDL may cause deposition of cholesterol in the
arteries and aorta and hence it is a direct risk factor for coronary heart
disease. LDL carries cholesterol from liver to the peripheral cells and smooth
muscles and cells of the arteries25. HDL promotes the removal of
cholesterol from peripheral cells and facilitates its delivery back to the
liver. Therefore, increased levels of HDL are desirable26.
In the ISO control group, a significant
increase in heart weight and heart weight to body weight ratio was observed
which was reversed by Draksharishta-T, Draksharishta-M and marketed Draksharishta
treatment in ISO-induced MI in albino rats. It suggests the cardio-protective
property of all these test formulations.
In the current investigation, ISO-induced
MI produced oxidative stress as indicated by increased heart lipid peroxides as
MDA and decreased heart GSH content. Pre-treatment with Draksharishta-T,
Draksharishta-M and marketed Draksharishta
significantly reduced heart lipid peroxides level as MDA and showed significant
rise in GSH content in ISO-induced MI in albino rats. Thus, all the test
formulations as Draksharishta-T, M and marketed Draksharishta maintained membrane integrity as evidenced by
decline in cardiac MDA levels.
In summary, the present study
strongly suggests that multiple mechanisms may be responsible for the
cardio-protective effect of Draksharishta-T, Draksharishta-M and marketed Draksharishta.
All these test formulations as Draksharishta-T, Draksharishta-M and marketed Draksharishta
produced myocardial adaptive changes (augmentation of endogenous antioxidants
as GSH) on chronic administration. In addition, they restored the integrity of
the myocardium, subsequent to ISO-induced oxidative stress. Draksharishta
contains rich concentration of polyphenolic compounds
which possess good antioxidant activity. Thus, the obtained result suggests
that presence of self generated alcohol could be beneficial in the faster
absorption of polyphenolic compounds present in Draksharishta which might be responsible for showing
scavenging of ISO-induced free radicals.
Thus, the present study provides
scientific basis for the cardio protective potential of Draksharishta
validating their usage in Ayurveda. Considering its
safety, efficacy and traditional acceptability, clinical trials should be
conducted to support its therapeutic use in ischemic heart diseases.
REFERENCES:
1.
Bolli R.
Myocardial ischemic metabolic disorder leading to cell death. Reviews of
Postgraduate Cardiology 1994; 13:649-53.
2.
Dhar ML, Dhar MM, Dhawan BN, Ray C.
Screening of Indian plants for biological activity. Journal of Experimental
Biology 1968; 6:232-47.
3.
Hertog MGL, Feskens EJM, Hollam PCH, Katan MB, Kromhout D. Dietary
antioxidant flavonoids and risk of coronary heart
diseases. Lancet 1993;342:1007-20.
4.
The Ayurvedic
Formulary of India, Part-I. 2000, 1st edition, The Controller of
Publications, Delhi, 15-16.
5.
Baydar NG, Ozkan G and Sagdic O. Total phenolic contents and antibacterial activities of grapes (Vitis vinifera L.)
extracts. Food Control 2004; 15: 335-339.
6.
Frankel EN, Kanner
J, German JB, Parks E and Kinsella JE. Inhibition of
oxidation of human low density lipoprotein by phenolic
substances in red wine. The Lancet 1993; 341(20): 454-457.
7.
Mayer AS, Yi OS, Person DA, Waterhouse DL
and Frankel EN. Inhibition of human low density lipoprotein oxidation in
relation to composition of phenolic antioxidants in
grapes (Vitis vinifera).
Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemistry 1997; 45: 1638-1643.
8.
Teissedre PL,
Frankel EN, Waterhouse AL, Peleg H and German GB.
Inhibition of in vitro human LDL
oxidation by phenolic antioxidants from grapes and
wines. Journal of Science, Food and Agriculture 1996; 70: 55-61.
9.
Waterhouse AL. Wine antioxidants may
reduce heart disease and cancer. Presentation of American Chemical Society,
Washington; 1994.
10.
Mishra S. Bhaisazya Kalpana Vigyan. Varanasi, India: Chaukambha
Surbharati Prakashan;
2005.p. 253-254.
11.
Alam M, Radhamani S, Ali U and Purushottam
KK. Microbiological Screening of Dhataki flowers.
Journal of Research in Ayurveda and Siddha 1984; 2(4):371-375.
12.
Rona G, Chapel CI, Balazs
T, Gaudry R. An infarct like myocardial lesion and
other toxic manifestations produced by isoproterenol
in the rat. Archives of Pathology 1959;76:443-55.
13.
Tripathi KD.
Essentials of Medical Pharmacology. 6th ed. New Delhi (India): Jaypee Brothers Medical Publishers Limited; 2008. p. 137-8,
537.
14.
Varley H.
Practical Clinical Biochemistry. 4th ed. NY: William Heinemann; 1967.p. 161-2.
15.
Lamprecht W,
Stan F, Weisser H, Heinz F. Determination of creatine phosphate and adenosine triphosphate
with creatine kinase. In:
Methods of Enzymatic analysis. Ed. HU Vergmeyer. NY:
Academic Press; 1974. 1776-8.
16.
Mohun AF,
Cook IGY. Simple methods for measuring serum levels of Glutamic
oxaloacetic and Glutamic pyruvic transaminases in routine
laboratories. Journal of Clinical Pathology 1957;10 (4):394-9.
17.
Allain CC,
Pool LS, Chan CS, Richmond W. Enzymatic determination of serum cholesterol.
Clinical Chemistry 1974;20:447-75.
18.
Friedewald WT,
Levy RI, Fredrickson DS. Estimation of the Concentration of Low-density
lipoprotein cholesterol in plasma, without use of the preparative
ultracentrifuge. Clinical Chemistry 1972;18
:499-502.
19.
Muller PH, Schmulling
RM, Liebich HM, Eggstein M.
A fully enzymatic triglyceride determination. Journal of Clinical Chemistry
1977;15:457-64.
20.
Ohkawa H, Ohisi N, Yagi K. Assay for lipid
peroxides in animal tissue by thiobarbituric acid
reaction. Analytical Biochemistry
1979;95:351-8.
21.
Ellman GL.
Tissue Sulphydril groups. Archives of Biochemistry & Biophysics
1959;82:72-7.
22.
Nirmala C, Puvanakrishnan R. Isoproterenol induced myocardial infarction in rats;
functional and biochemical alterations. Medicine Science and Research
1994;22:575-7.
23.
Haenen GR, Veerman M, Bast A. Reduction of beta adrenoceptor
functions by oxidative stress in heart. Free Radical Biology and Medicine
1990;9:279-88.
24.
Tappia PS, Heta T, Dhalla NS. Role of
oxidative stress in catecholamine induced changes in cardiac sarcolemmal Ca2+ transport. Archives of
Biochemistry and Biophysics 2001;377:85-92.
25.
Pederson TR. Low density lipoprotein cholesterol lowering
is and will be the key to the future of lipid management. American Journal of
Cardiology 2001;87(5A):8B-12B.
26.
Bolden WE, Pearson TA. Raising low levels
of High density lipoprotein cholesterol is an important target of therapy.
American Journal of Cardiology 2000;85(5):645-50.
Received
on 18.05.2014 Modified on 12.06.2014
Accepted
on 25.06.2014 ©A&V Publications All right reserved
Research J. Science and Tech. 6(3):
July- Sept., 2014; Page 151-155